Sunday, May 17, 2026
Home Blog Page 4063

Corruption’s shame in Real Estate

Addis Ababa has been undergoing a facelift as luxury apartments have mushroomed alongside, office buildings and villas. Its urban areas have also expanded to include the former rural areas surrounding it. Real estate development has dramatically changed the city, giving it a modern look and feel. However, the continuous housing demand and scarcity of land has created corrupt practices such as grabbing land for many years with unfinished or no construction.
The new administration of the Addis Ababa region has taken action recently to address the land grab and corrupt practices which to me plausible and long overdue. This action will set the standard. In a similar note, the council need to also consider and revise standards and operating procedures to issue construction permits, tender processes etc that is currently the bottleneck that hinders completion of projects that actually gave the city a nickname “the ever constructing city” where building construction never ends. One asks, how long it took to finish Midroc Ethiopia main office (where resources is not a problem), why are some real estate projects still not finished for over 10 years. Such questions should be on the burden of the city council to further look into.
It is a known truth within Real Estate Developers that many are guilty of malpractice and playing foul over the construction development life cycle is an ubiquitous phenomena for most if not least.
From the outset, tenders are hijacked. This is particularly a known practice for large scale construction. A group of contractors /bidders gang up and decide what to put as an offer in each bid and know who will be the winning bidder. This will do two things. One, as all are bidding anyways, it will allow them to act as if they are competing with the outside world but in essence it is an orchestrated action. Secondly, the winner bidder will have a jacked up price but is the lower than it’s setup counterparts. The winning contractor pays the rest some amount, which is known as RENT, (mostly added to the project bid proposal, inflated price) and everyone is happy except the project itself. By the way, this could also be used for any tender including purchase of raw materials, food items etc.
The other corruption method is delaying the project itself. Particularly of interest to me is housing as housing market prices keeps skyrocketing. Delay in completing a project is definitely costly and today, it is does not burden the developer but the public. The developer will take this chance to request more money from the poor public or ask to forfeit the house etc. The scandal with Access Real Estate still lives in the public knowledge. The city council needs to have a mitigation plan so that it never allows such schemes to happen again.
Another delay strategy which is ongoing and has dealt a major blow especially to the Diaspora community has been going on with the Country Club Developer known as CCD. There is a scam going on that each region of the country must solve. I know a very close friend of mine (Diaspora) suffering from continuous requests for additional money to complete a project for which an agreement was signed more than 10 years ago. As of this write up, the construction has not been completed but additional funding had been continuously asked for by CCD. Sadly, the negligence of the city audit has allowed the contractor to continue to build phase 9 and so forth while phase 2 properties are hanging within the construction compound held hostage for additional funding exceeding the original signed and agreed upon contract. Construction never commences once money is received as CCD knows that clients are remote. Only small amount of work immediately starts when client shows up at CCD office. It seems to me that CCD systemically wants these clients to sell back at the original agreed project price to CCD as today’s price exponentially inflated and CCD is in its 9th or 10th phases of construction. Confusing to the public is why a developer holds property plan by it’s name for properties that have been funded by 50% or more. Can the city council help alleviate this corrupt practices by retroactively following up case by case and refund funds to public possibly with penalty.
I was honestly taken off guard when I saw CCD’s owner, in Shashmene with the Prime Minister on a visit to an agro industrial area. Curious minds would ask how such a developer could be given as big a project as this while not diligently and most of all professionally completing previous commitments.
I believe the elected officials must address the real estate scandal with utmost priority. The development of a city plan does on end with issuing a tender or leasing a plot of land. The City must protect the public’s interest from start to finish. In most developed countries there are penalties attached to delayed projects. Major excuses are seen to lie around scarcity or escalation of raw material prices which sometimes is a valid reason but must be verified. No builder must hold the plan hostage for a delayed house and other projects where more than a certain amount of payment is made for the property. Last but not least, the City must include as criterion for issuing or renewing developers’ licenses based on merits that addresses professionalism, past construction excellence, not by how many trucks one owns. This of course enforces standards as it calls for downgrading or upgrading and revoking of construction licenses.

By Getahun Alemu

Enat Bank’s paid up capital nears NBE standard

Enat Bank, which is one of the late comers to the financial industry, has exceeded expectations during the previous fiscal year.
The bank’s annual report which came out recently showed the bank earned high profits and approached the paid up standard for the banking sector.
During the 2017/18 financial year the bank earned 750 million birr in total income which is an increase of 230 million birr compared with the 2016/17 financial year. The total amount of income has surpassed the target the bank set for the year. According to the report of Enat Bank, their goal was to generate 736 million birr in the 2017/18 fiscal year. However, the achievement went up 2 percent compared with the target.
For the stated period the bank earned a gross profit of 216.5 million birr before tax, which is an increase of around 50 percent. A year ago the gross profit before tax was 146.5 million birr. According Enat’s external audit report they have secured 159 million birr in gross profits after tax. During the 2016/17 fiscal year that amount was 112 million birr.
Their after tax earnings per share also increased 18.4 percent compared with 16.8 percent a year ago.
The bank’s deposit mobilization was a third of what it was a year ago. The report indicated that the bank’s deposit reached 4.9 billion birr which is a 33 percent increase. At the same time the number of depositors rose to over 70,000.
The bank disbursed 3.3 billion birr, which is 10 percent higher than the target, in loans and advances, according to the report. The bank had a goal for outstanding loans and advances of 3.1 billion birr. From the total of loan shares constructions and exports took the majority at 18.6 and 19.6 percentage respectively.
Enat’s paid up capital has now reached almost one billion birr. This is an 8 percent increase over the targets set for the year. The bank’s goal was for paid up capital to be 902 million birr, while the actual achievement was 971 million. The National Bank of Ethiopia, wants all banks to have one billion birr in paid up capital. The bank’s total assets were of 6.5 billion birr as of June 30, 2018 as compared to 4.9 billion birr a year ago.

Pardons, ethnic clash tops court report

0

The Office of the Attorney General (OAG) announced that it granted pardons to 503 individuals in recognition of the Christmas holiday. The release was made by prioritizing women and elderly in addition to the other legal requirements. The office also announced that 13,122 certificates were issued for individuals who applied for amnesty issued by the Parliament, excluding the beneficiaries form Gambela, Somali and Afar Regions because they had not sent the appropriate information yet.
The proclamation is effective over six months beginning in July 20, 2018 and goes until January 21, 2019 so people can petition for pardons up during that time period. There are 13 crimes eligible for pardons.
Zinabu Tule, the public relations director told journalists that their office is investigating clashes that have occurred throughout the country.
Hawassa
In Hawassa prosecutors have filed charges against multiple people for instigating violence in clashes involving Wolytia and Sidama nationalities.
In one case police presented evidence against 67 people suspected of contributing to fighting in Hawassa prison. The suspects include one high official from the prison administration and five members of the police force, according to Fekadu Tsega, Director at the OAG. The charges are based on conflict between the Wolyita and Sidam Nationalities in the prison.
The second set of charges involves the former city mayor and 33 other people for leading violence which broke out in Hawassa Town. Not every one of those 33 people are in custody as some have fled. There are 75 other people being charged with related crimes as well which Fekadu says are still being investigated.
Burayu
The clash between the Burayu and Addis Ababa youth is another event under investigation. Police believe that the violence stemmed from fights which got out of control and then were flamed by rumors and innuendo. For example, Fekadu talked about one false claim that made its way to broadcast media saying a little girl was killed and covered with the emblem of the Oromo Liberation Front (OLF).
A woman spoke with the media and said she saw a little girl being raped and killed. This became a major instigator for violence between Oromo and Addis Ababa youth. She later apologized saying that she made the claim because she thought it could have happened and she wanted to ‘inflate the activity’. According to the suspects under custody, they participated in violence because they saw their friends being beaten by the Addis Ababa youth when they tried to welcome their leaders to the capital city.
The situation escalated when youth tried to paint an emblem on city roads, according to Fekadu.
With regards to the events in Burayu town the Attorney General pressed charges against 109 people, while 28 are still at large. Three hundred and twenty one people were released because there was not enough evidence to try them. One of the difficulties in this case is that people traveled from Addis Ababa to fight in Burayu and then left so it was hard to determine who was involved. There are at least four police included in the charges and one station commander from Addis Ababa.
The head was charged as she and her colleagues were unable to prevent a child from being killed by a mob for wearing a t-shirt that had similar colors to the OLF emblem.
According to the update, there were about 37 individuals killed in Burayu and 28 in Addis Ababa. Two people were burnt beyond recognition.
“Political appointees and security forces actively participated in the violence,” said Fekadu discussing places like Burayu, Hawassa, Benishangul and others.

Duty-free privileges partially banned

0

The Government has temporally banned some duty-free privileges until the Ministry of Revenue (MoR) and the Custom Commission finish reforms targeted to stop abuse. Lack of standard on how duty-free privilege is being given out had been damaging the country’s income according to Adanach Abebe, Minister of the MoR.
When the General Auditor of the Federal Auditor General (OFAG), Gemechu Dubiso, addressed parliament last week he said people were abusing duty free privileges.
Approval of duty free requests is disorganized and lack clear standards, he stressed.
“The government gives up to 60 billion birr in revenue over a year for duty-free privileges without seeing as much benefit as much as we are waving,” said Gemechu. “The Ministry hasn’t follow-up with imported items permitted and people are bringing in more items than they are entitled to.”
He stressed that many investors re-sell items on the market, usually rebar.
Companies, he added, that are permitted to export their products are engaged in the local market sales. When the government waives its revenue it tries to encourage exports but these companies are not helping with that goal.
Adanech Abebe, agreed saying that actions are being taken to stop duty free abuse.
“There is a practice, we found different Bills of Quality (BoQ) were given for the same projects if we look at hotel projects as an example,” said Adanech. “So we need to have a proper standard for the way privileged projects operate.”
The minister stated that legal gaps are the main reasons duty free privileges are being handled in a disorganized manner and that this would soon change.
Non-centralized service is another problem as 18 organizations give out duty-free privileges, which is unique to Ethiopia.
“We are considering how to create a centralized body to give duty free privileges,” said Adanech.
They are also looking at developing a manual to help alleviate the problem.