A Federal High Court ruling that overturned mandatory Value Added Tax (VAT) registration for lawyers whose annual taxable transactions fall below the statutory threshold faces a fresh legal and practical challenge following the Council of Ministers’ approval of a regulation requiring professional service providers to register once their annual taxable transactions exceed 100,000 birr.
The new regulation has reignited debate over the limits of executive authority in setting tax obligations, particularly whether the Cabinet can introduce a separate VAT registration threshold for professionals when the existing VAT Proclamation establishes a general threshold of two million birr.
The dispute follows a decision by the Federal High Court’s Lideta Division First Instance Administrative Procedure Bench that partially invalidated Ministry of Finance Directive No. 1104/2017. The court ruled that requiring professionals to register for VAT regardless of their annual transaction volume exceeded the Ministry’s delegated authority and conflicted with the existing legal framework.
However, the Cabinet-approved amendment to the VAT Regulation has introduced a new dimension to the controversy, potentially allowing the government to pursue its policy through a higher-level regulatory instrument rather than the ministerial directive rejected by the court.
The case was initiated by eight legal practitioners who challenged the legality of Directive No. 1104/2017 and its requirement that professional service providers register for VAT irrespective of their annual business transactions.
Their challenge came after broader tax reforms repealed the Turnover Tax (TOT) regime through Income Tax Amendment Proclamation No. 1395/2017. The Ministry subsequently introduced the directive as part of efforts to address revenue gaps affecting regional states and city administrations.
Under the directive, lawyers and other professional service providers were required to register for VAT regardless of whether their annual taxable transactions reached the two-million-birr threshold applicable to other businesses.
The applicants argued that the requirement contradicted Article 12(1) of VAT Proclamation No. 1341/2016, which establishes mandatory VAT registration for businesses whose annual taxable transactions exceed two million birr. The proclamation also allows voluntary registration for eligible businesses whose annual taxable transactions exceed one million birr.
Although Articles 12(2) and 12(4) authorise the Minister of Finance to adjust monetary thresholds in response to changing economic conditions, the applicants maintained that these powers do not permit the Ministry to eliminate the threshold entirely or introduce a separate obligation based solely on professional status.
They further argued that the directive improperly applied income tax-related bookkeeping requirements to VAT registration, creating unequal treatment among taxpayers with comparable annual turnover.
Citing Article 25 of the FDRE Constitution, the applicants maintained that requiring a lawyer with annual taxable transactions of 1.9 million birr to register for and collect VAT, while not imposing the same registration requirement on a trader with equivalent turnover, raised questions of equality before the law.
The Ministry of Finance defended the directive, arguing that professional services constitute high-value-added economic activities with relatively limited input tax credits.
The Ministry maintained that the measure was necessary to compensate for revenue losses following the abolition of the turnover tax system and to strengthen domestic revenue mobilisation.
It also invoked the emergency provisions of Article 11(1) of the Federal Administrative Procedure Proclamation No. 1183/2012, arguing that the circumstances justified adopting the directive without following the usual public consultation process.
However, the court rejected the Ministry’s principal arguments, identifying three major legal shortcomings.
First, the judges ruled that the authority to adjust the two-million-birr threshold did not give the Ministry unlimited discretion to abolish it. Introducing a zero-threshold requirement for an entire professional category went beyond its delegated powers.
Second, the court emphasised the hierarchy of laws, noting that an administrative directive cannot override or contradict a proclamation enacted by Parliament. The Ministry could not use a lower-level legal instrument to establish an obligation inconsistent with the primary legislation.
Third, the court found that the Ministry had failed to demonstrate compliance with mandatory procedural requirements for issuing administrative directives.
Under Article 11(2) of Proclamation No. 1183/2012, an agency seeking to bypass public consultation on emergency grounds must provide a written justification explaining the circumstances. The court found that the Ministry had not submitted the required documentation to substantiate its emergency argument.
As the court proceedings approached their conclusion, the Ministry secured Council of Ministers approval for an amendment to the VAT Regulation, introducing a separate registration threshold for professional service providers.
The new provision requires professional service providers to register for VAT when their annual taxable transactions exceed 100,000 birr, while retaining the general two-million-birr threshold for other taxpayers.
“The new measure represents a significant change in the government’s approach to regulating VAT obligations for professionals,” said Ketema Adane, managing partner and co-founder of Ethio Alliance Advocates LLP.
Unlike the previous directive, which effectively required registration without a monetary threshold, the Cabinet-approved regulation establishes a specific financial limit. It also introduces the requirement through a regulation approved by the Council of Ministers rather than a ministerial directive.
Ketema told Capital that these changes could make the new measure more difficult to challenge using the same arguments that led to the court’s decision against the Ministry.
Nevertheless, the new threshold raises a fundamental question: whether the Council of Ministers has the authority to establish a separate VAT registration threshold for professional services when the parent proclamation sets a general threshold of two million birr.
The distinction between a ministerial directive and a Cabinet regulation may strengthen the government’s procedural position, but it does not automatically resolve questions about consistency with the enabling proclamation.
The regulation also raises questions about the scope of the existing administrative judicial review framework.
The original applicants relied on the Federal Administrative Procedure Proclamation to challenge the Ministry’s directive. However, the framework governing administrative directives does not necessarily provide the same direct judicial review mechanism for regulations issued by the Council of Ministers.
As a result, challenging the new regulation could require a different legal approach.
Legal analysts argue that although a Cabinet regulation is a higher-level instrument than a ministerial directive, it cannot override a proclamation enacted by the House of Peoples’ Representatives.
The issue, therefore, is not simply whether the Cabinet has introduced a numerical threshold, but whether that threshold is consistent with the authority granted under the VAT Proclamation.
Possible avenues identified in the draft include seeking constitutional interpretation through the Council of Constitutional Inquiry and the House of the Federation, or contesting individual tax assessments through the Tax Appeal Commission. Whether either route is available would depend on the nature of the challenge and the applicable jurisdictional requirements.
Any subsequent proceedings could clarify whether the government has the authority to impose a separate registration threshold on professional service providers. The dispute also highlights broader questions about the relationship between tax policy, delegated legislative powers and administrative accountability in Ethiopia.





