What’s Out Addis in partnership with Hilton Addis Ababa, the Embassy of Spain and the Embassy of Belgium is going to hold “The Big Art Sale”. This event will take place on Saturday March 31 from 10 am to 6pm at the Hilton Hotel, under a large tent within the parking lot. The tent will be filled with over 1,000 works by over 100 artists, making it a record breaking artistic event in Ethiopian contemporary art history.
What’s Out Addis has, over the last 18 years, organized some of the most exciting artistic events in Addis Ababa. Under the leadership of Yasser Bagersh, the organization has helped foster and nurture the artistic community through art exhibitions, art tours and large scale art festivals.
This year, the Big Art Sale, has moved to the Hilton Hotel to accommodate this ambitious goal of presenting the large number of artists under one roof.
The importance of the event is to support the artistic community. Any profit made from the event will support the charity decided by all the partners involved in the project.
The entry fee is 50 birr. The event is not targeting only art lovers but also families who will enjoy it. There will be food stands, entertainment, a children’s corner and other fun activities.
The Big Art Sale to show case the largest art collection in Ethiopia
A networked solution to education reform
Each year, millions of children are unable to attend school, and many who do are not receiving the quality education they deserve. But a consensus about how to address the problem is emerging, and new international forums known as “peer action networks” are providing the framework to implement solutions.
By Amy Black and Alexis Menten
Around the world, some 250 million children are unable to attend school, and many who do have access to a classroom are not learning the skills they need to succeed in life. And, despite a growing consensus about the systemic nature of the challenges affecting education, there is less agreement about how address those systemic challenges. Yet 2018 is shaping up to be a promising year for global efforts to improve educational access and quality.
One reason is the emergence of so-called peer action networks, which facilitate knowledge-sharing globally and encourage continuous improvement locally. Such networks, if organized properly, could offer a partial solution to the systemic challenges affecting education.
There are numerous peer groups tackling some of the planet’s most difficult problems, but two that are associated with our organizations are worth highlighting. One is the Joint Learning Network for Universal Health Coverage (JLN), a community of practitioners and policymakers from 30 countries supported by Results for Development and other development partners. The other is the Asia Society’s Global Cities Education Network (GCEN), which facilitates improvements in urban education systems throughout North America and Asia.
Each of these international peer networks has produced local results. For example, in 2016, Denver Public Schools in Colorado – a GCEN member – created the CareerConnect program, which provides workplace-based learning opportunities for students. The program draws on lessons from vocational education systems in Hong Kong, Melbourne, and Singapore – all GCEN member cities – as well as Switzerland, to help graduates prepare for life after high school.
Similarly, the JLN has made significant progress helping developing countries move toward universal health coverage. Network support has enabled members to navigate technical roadblocks and secure political support at home. Adapting the JLN model to support officials of national education ministries could produce comparable gains in education in many countries.
Both of these networks offer a global platform for local practitioners to devise solutions and drive innovation. And both are organized around five principles that we believe successful peer groups – in education or any sector – should strive to incorporate into their own work.
First, networks bring together leaders who are facing similar issues in varying contexts. International peer action networks are most effective when they are cross-cultural; we have found that connecting disparate groups that are working toward similar goals often produces unexpected solutions that are more robust.
Second, the “peer” component of these networks is strongly emphasized. Members are equally empowered to set priorities and contribute to discussions. Networked learning is most successful when participants feel a sense of ownership with respect to outcomes.
Third, membership includes those with the authority and the ability to influence change. For example, many challenges at the national or city level in education planning require both political and technical solutions. For a network to be effective, policymakers and practitioners must work in concert to find solutions to shared challenges.
Fourth, the JLN and the GCEN are committed to measuring collective and individual progress. While gauging success in education can be difficult, especially across contexts, peer action networks must be oriented toward achieving results, and that means measuring their effectiveness. Moreover, accountability metrics should be derived from systems that members are already using at home.
Finally, these networks strive to be sustainable. To drive large-scale and lasting change through a network in any sector, but especially in global education, requires consistent vision, staffing, and financial resources. Peer group participants cannot simultaneously work as policymakers or practitioners and collaboratively run a network organization. Budgeting for central teams to manage the technical support to members and operations of the network is critical to success.
Unfortunately, very little education funding is currently set aside for investments in new learning networks. Increasing investment in peer action networks could help to bolster leadership and implementation capacity – critical to expand learning opportunities around the world, a key objective of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals.
There are no easy solutions to providing high-quality education to every child on the planet. However, as the growth in peer action networks demonstrates, global education leaders are not in this struggle alone. When like-minded policymakers and practitioners share ideas and collaborate on solutions, the world’s educational challenges become a little less daunting.
Amy Black is a senior fellow at Results for Development.
Alexis Menten is Executive Director for Program Development at the Center for Global Education at Asia Society.
Protectionism the US trade strategy
President Donald Trump has long been keen to defend workers from the “carnage” of “bad trade deals.” To that end, President Tramp signed on 8 March 2018 an order that imposes tariffs on steel and aluminum imports from all foreign countries, while carving out an exception for Canada and Mexico for now while North America Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) negotiations are under way. President Tramp, joined by steel and aluminum workers, signed a companion proclamation, one on steel and one on aluminum, institution a tariff of 25% on steel and 10% on aluminum imports.
President Trump a lso threatened the European Union (EU) with trade barriers on automobiles and could take even more measures on intellectual property rights and technology goods. It is more plausible than not that this is the beginning of a costly tit-for-tat whereby United States trade protection will be countered by others. The EU for example warned the United States not to take such measures.
To this effect, EU Trade Ministers agreed at a meeting on 27 February 2018 that they would respond with counter-measures if the United States brings in import tariffs on steel and aluminum. Matthias Machning, German Deputy Economy Minister stated that the introduction of tariffs on steel and aluminum by the United States is incompatible with the World Trade Organization (WTO) rules and unjustifiable on national security grounds.
The bad news is that a fully-fledged trade war would create serious economic damage. Recent estimations by Ralph Ossa from the University of Chicago indicate that a global trade war, resulting in a rise in trade barriers for all countries, would slash real incomes by an average 3.4%. At the global level, this would correspond to a loss of almost one full year of growth efforts. Ralph Ossa argued that, President Trump’s such move is surprising in that it will negatively impact the United States economy, although the extent of harm would be limited to the loss of jobs in the user industries of the protected sector.
According to Ralph Ossa, this can be illustrated with the case of the United States steel safeguard tariffs between March 2002 and December 2003. Back in 2002, mounting competitive pressures on the steel industry led President George W. Bush to impose safeguard tariffs ranging between 8% and 30% on ten steel product groups, with a total of 272 tariff lines. Steel imports from NAFTA countries, from other preferential trade agreement parties (Jordan and Israel) and from 100 developing countries were exempted. Moreover, around 1,000 firm-specific exemptions were granted by the United States Trade Representative at the time.
Dr. Agnieszka Gehringer, a Senior Research Analyst at the Flossbach von Storch Research Institute stated that, as a result of trade restrictions, United States imports of steel products declined by 5% between 2002 and 2003, bringing the steel industry’s trade deficit down by 28%. However, immediately after the protection ended, import growth rebounded and contributed to a rapid widening of the industry’s trade deficit, above the levels from pre-protectionist era.
The protection of the steel industry produced negative spillover effects to other parts of the United States economy. Steel is a key input in several industries, among others manufacture of basic metals, manufacture of fabricated metal products, manufacture of electrical equipment and manufacture of machinery and equipment not elsewhere classified. Taken together, the steel-using industries generated in 2001 far more value added than did the steel industry itself and employed 57 workers for every employee in the steel industry.
According to Dr. Agnieszka Gehringer, nine WTO members (Brazil, China, Chinese Taipei, the EU, Japan, Korea, New Zealand, Norway and Switzerland) opposed the safeguard measures in the WTO. It was found that the safeguards violated WTO rules by failing to show a “causal link” between increased imports and “serious injury” on the United States side. Also, the United States government did not provide comprehensive and appropriate evidence of “unforeseen developments” of steel imports explaining their increase.
Due to the continuation of non-compliance of the United States with the WTO ruling, the EU was authorized to raise retaliatory tariffs on United States goods. It targeted, among others, citrus fruits and textiles, with the aim to build up internal opposition to the United States protectionism among various United States industries. Safeguard measures on steel were eventually terminated by the United States in December 2003.
Dr. Agnieszka Gehringer further noted that there should be no doubt that unfair trading practices undermine the harmonious functioning of the global trading order. But the WTO’s dispute resolution has exactly the aim to assist discordant trading partners in a peaceful resolution of trade tensions. As a matter of fact, the United States enjoys an above-average success rate in disputes that have been decided at the WTO since its foundation in 1995. At the same time, some WTO rules might be indeed outdated and could be renegotiated to better reflect the changing nature of trade today.
Finally, as Ralph Ossa said, the lack of an investment treaty between the United States and China adds considerable fuel to the flames. After all, if such an investment treaty existed, it would assure fair access to reciprocal markets for multinationals. It is obvious that President Donald Trump’s protectionist measures and pledges will cause a tit-for-tat trade conflict or at least elements thereof. Smaller muscle flexing with respect to single industries would probably not harm the overall economic picture. However, a fully-fledged trade war would be detrimental to both the United States and its trading partners.
Steve Halle of Birmingham University stated that the current Trump administration’s strategy reflects a false diagnosis of the underlying problem of chronic current account deficits registered by the United States. As long as United States excess consumption is financed by savings from abroad, there is no economic reason for current account deficits to improve. Protectionism only reallocates the deficits among sectors.
Equally significant, Steve Halle noted, under the twin deficit scenario, these trade deficit could get even worse, should the recent major tax cuts significantly worsen the outlook for the United States fiscal balance. With regard to protectionism and trade wars, President Donald Trump should heed the warning of his illustrious predecessor Thomas Jefferson that “the most successful war seldom pays for its losses.”
Irish relations
Next year, will be the 25th anniversary of Ireland opening an embassy in Ethiopia. The two nations continue to have a strong partnership. Ireland is one of the key donor countries for Ethiopia through Irish Aid. Mostly focusing on sustainable developmental cooperation projects, Ireland continues to provide funding to key endeavors in health, education and agriculture, among others, in Ethiopia. Capital spoke to Sonja Hyland, Ireland’s Ambassador to Ethiopia about the over two decade long friendship between the two countries
Capital: If you could give us a briefing on the current relationship between Ethiopia and Ireland.
Sonja Hyland: Next year will be the 25th anniversary of opening our embassy and the 25th anniversary of the partnership we have with the government and people of Ethiopia in relation to development cooperation.
We opened an embassy here in 1994 and from the beginning invested quite heavily in a partnership with Ethiopia especially around development priorities; the health sector, education sector, social protection, gender issues, livelihoods and agriculture and that sort of range both in terms of basic public services for citizens and also in terms of rural livelihoods and agriculture in the productive sector, particularly the rural agriculture sector.
Our partnership has grown obviously, now we have partnerships in the cultural area, beginning in areas of trade and investment, we have an air link; there is now a direct flight to Dublin. So it is a partnership that has grown beyond the initial partnership which was based on developmental cooperation, but we do still have a very strong developmental cooperation here which is the largest one we have in the world.
We spend about 30 million Euros which is about one billion birr a year with government, UN and NGO partners in support of social protection, health, gender issues, governance, rural livelihoods and agricultural development.
Capital: What about looking at investment relations; that is something Ethiopia is looking for as well.
Hyland: We have had some interest from Irish companies, I would say it is relatively modest interest at this stage because Ireland is relatively a small domestic market; we are four and a half million people. So we are not a huge economy, but having said that we have very successful multinational companies.
One of the things everyone knows about Ireland is it is one of the largest recipients of US foreign direct investment on per capita terms but the thing people don’t know is that Ireland is actually the 9th largest investor in the US as well. So we actually do have quite a few companies that are of a size and a scale that can invest abroad.
I would say that markets in Africa are underrepresented in terms of Irish companies because I think most Irish companies which have grown first into a European market then to the States, Australia, and beginning in Asia quite a lot now, and Latin America starting. There is a strong interest in a number of African markets, but it is not somewhere that has been fully explored by Irish companies.
Having said that we do have some investments from mobile technology companies; M-Birr for instance which is a money transfer system by a French-Irish company, we have some Irish companies in the agribusiness sector as well, we have had interests in the manufacturing sector.
I think it is definitely a relationship that needs to develop further and one of the things we have been talking about with the government whether we might share our experiences on attracting foreign direct investment because as I said we are one of the most successful countries in the world in terms of attracting foreign direct investment and that has to do with a whole range of issues with the regulatory environment, education and skills, the taxation environment, governance; all sorts of issues that have added up to make Ireland an attractive prospect for FDI.
Capital: Looking at development cooperation, there is Irish Aid which has been a partner for development for a long time now. How strong is that partnership right now?
Hyland: This year we will be spending 30 million Euros in Ethiopia on a development cooperation program and that is part of a strategic commitment between 2014 and 2018 of a 130 million Euros overall; so this is the final year and it is 30 million Euros.
The humanitarian element has unfortunately grown in the last couple of years. When we started our current strategy in 2014 we didn’t envision much at all on the humanitarian side but now because of the last three consecutive years of drought and because of the conflict between the Somali and Oromia regions, we have been forced to adjust some of our spending to put more in the humanitarian basket.
We have just announced that we will provide the government with three million Euros following the launching of the Ethiopian Humanitarian and Disaster Resilience Plan; that is a commitment we take seriously.
Capital: It is also mentioned that there needs to be a sustainable way of addressing issues instead of depending on material aid. What has Irish Aid done to archive that?
Hyland: I think all our programs are focused on exactly that which is basically sustainability and reaching development gains and priorities the government has set in a way that is sustainable. For example the social protection and Productive Safety Net Program (PSNP) we are one of the key donors in that, we are actually the chair of the donor group this year for PSNP.
It is exactly one of those programs which is the key to breaking that cycle of humanitarian crisis by supporting them in a way that allows them to improve their productive capacity and graduate from the PSNP program; that is our biggest investment from the 30 million Euros a year, 10 million goes to PSNP.
Similarly in the health sector what we are doing is helping to strengthen the national health system so again we are not building our own clinics or bringing our own doctors. The support goes into a pool of funding for the Ministry of Health to deliver on the priorities that has been set by Ethiopia.
Agriculture and rural livelihood is a key piece of the resilience strategy in any country. In Ireland we have the experience; initially we were subsistence farmers like many people in Ethiopia are now and we moved through that to a more productive agricultural economy and now we are one of the biggest agricultural exporters per capita in the world.
Our agricultural support even in the last seven years went up by 60 percent and so we have not only increased in volume but really increased in value addition. This is something we would like to share with Ethiopia as well, and while the our embassy will be here for a long time, Irish Aid over time will not be here because it will not be needed. For that reason our programs are focused on sustainable development, resilience and basically alleviation out of poverty.
Capital: One of the biggest issues for donor countries is that there is shortage in funding due to many humanitarian crises, how are you dealing with that? What about the issue of accountability?
Hyland: We have put a larger percentage of our development funding into humanitarian aid, we have to do that because we have to meet immediate needs, but at the same time, you don’t want that situation to continue forever because you are in a situation where you are not investing in development and resilience and a long term future.
Accountability is always an issue in a humanitarian context because by definition it is always a crisis, it’s always a confusing situation that involves a significant displacement of people so I guess what we try to do is work with the government, with the UN and NGOs to make sure they have robust accountable systems in place and have a dialogue with the government on how important that accountability is.
Capital: Ethiopia is currently implementing a State of Emergency. What is Ireland’s thought on this?
Hyland: You probably saw the EU statement and Ireland is part of the EU and part of that statement and we would associate ourselves with that.
From our perspectives what we see in Ethiopia is that there is a significant demand from Ethiopians for political reform. The government and the current Prime Minister, when the first State of Emergency was announced, committed very openly and publically to reform and back in January again the EPRDF made a very clear statement around understanding the pace of reform was not enough and further reform needed to be prioritized and more rapidly implemented. We agree with that.
The State of Emergency, again we would associate with the EU statement; we don’t necessarily see that as a helpful element in demonstrating commitment in political reform and economic reform. At the end of the day it is the decision of the Ethiopian government but from our perspective, we feel that a more rapid implementation of economic and political reform would be perhaps more easily done without the State of Emergency.
Capital: On a lighter note, we have heard that a famous monument in Addis Ababa was lit up in green, tell us about that.
Hyland: This is a campaign called the Global Greening Campaign, it started in 2010 globally and it started small, maybe 20 to 30 monuments around the world going green on Saint Patrick’s Day which is our national day and green is the national color of Ireland.
The idea is to highlight Ireland on Saint Patrick’s Day by lighting up monuments in green in reminder of Ireland, Irish culture and heritage, tourism possibilities in terms of coming to Ireland. The second thing it highlights is our long standing friendship with many nations.
In case of Ethiopia this year we decided to green the lion in front of the National Theater. The reason we chose the lion is because it is an all Ethiopian symbol and the symbol of Addis Ababa so we thought it would be a good monument to green to demonstrate the partnership between Ethiopia and Ireland.


